Short answer: yes.
Long answer: also yes, but let’s talk about what “professionally designed” actually means.
Golden rule: A less than perfect website is always better than no website at all.
I know, I know — there’s always a board member’s nephew who “does websites,” or a volunteer who swears they can handle it in a weekend. And maybe they can get something up that technically functions. But there’s a difference between a website that exists and a website that works. A website that builds trust with donors, tells your story clearly, and doesn’t make people click away before they’ve had a chance to understand what you do.
Here’s the thing about your website: it’s often the first thing someone sees when they Google you. A major donor gets your name from a friend, they search you up, and within about ten seconds they’ve formed an opinion about whether your organization is credible. A site that looks like it was built in 2012 and hasn’t been touched since sends a message — and not the one you want (unless maybe that was an intentional design choice).
What “professional” actually means
I’m not saying you need to spend $30,000 on a custom-built site with animations and a brand identity system. For most small-to-mid-size nonprofits, that’s not realistic or necessary (but maybe one day). What I am saying is that your website needs to do a few things well:
It needs to load fast and look good on a phone. More than half of your visitors are on mobile. If your site is hard to navigate on a small screen, you’re losing people.
It needs to be clear about who you are and what you do. Within a few seconds of landing on your homepage, a visitor should understand your mission. Not after reading three paragraphs, within a few seconds.
It needs to make giving easy. Your donation button should be obvious. Your donation page should be simple. Every extra click between “I want to give” and “I gave” costs you conversions.
It needs to look like you take yourselves seriously. That doesn’t mean flashy. It means clean, consistent, and intentional.
What does this actually cost?
More than a volunteer weekend, but less than you probably fear. Platforms like Squarespace, Wix, and WordPress with a good theme can produce professional-looking results for under $1,000 if you have someone with a good eye and some patience. If you need custom functionality, like an integrated donation page, a calendar, a volunteer signup workflow — budget a bit more, or look for a nonprofit-focused web agency or a skilled freelancer.
There are also organizations that offer pro bono or discounted web services to nonprofits. It’s worth asking in your network before you assume you’re paying full freight.
The one thing I’ll push back on
Sometimes nonprofits treat a website redesign like a major capital project — something that needs six months of planning, a committee, and seventeen rounds of approval. It doesn’t. Done is better than perfect. A clean, functional site you can update yourself is worth more than a beautifully designed one you have to submit a help ticket to change.
On the flip side of that, I’ve also seen organizations make a decision to update the website without appropriate staff input. If you’re running even a mid-sized organization with multiple departments, you need to at least address how and if the website is serving each piece of the organization and plan from there.
Build something good. Keep it current. Make it easy for people to give and connect. That’s really all it needs to do.
I’m not an expert!
I’m just your run of the mill development and programming staffer who’s had the lovely responsibility of building/maintaining/touching up the website thrown onto their plate more than once! Here are some of my favorite resources when it comes to website development, design, etc.:
- Mowgli – an amazing web and graphic design company that I have had the pleasure of working with three times now!!
- Pixel Lighthouse
- Wired Impact
Pro Tip:
Whether you employ the help of a designer or not, it’s always good to have a good reference list of websites you like and disklike. There are a lot of rules in website design, especially when it comes to user experience so it’s always good to set your reference point high.
Some of my favorites are: