Why Bonterra’s EveryAction is Good but Complicated

Abstract

Is your nonprofit ready for an enterprise CRM, or are you about to buy a very expensive headache? EveryAction (now part of the Bonterra family) is one of the most powerful, all-in-one fundraising and advocacy platforms on the market—boasting best-in-class email tools, customizable forms, and native organizing features. But behind the glossy features lies a steep learning curve, multi-year contract traps, and a high price tag that can overwhelm a small development team. Read our honest review to discover how to scale into the platform without data regret, who should actually use it, and why you need a dedicated staff "champion" to keep this powerhouse infrastructure from going to waste.

The learning curve is steep. The implementation takes longer than you think. And if you don't have someone on staff (or a consultant you trust) who can manage the system with some real fluency, you're going to end up with a very expensive tool you're only using 20% of.

Background

EveryAction is one of those CRMs where once it enters your sphere, it never really leaves. I got sucked into it’s orbit about 5 years ago and have worked with two organizations using the platform. There have been a lot of ups and downs but here’s the honest review from a fundraiser who has primarily worked with small to midsize nonprofits.

Let me be honest with you: EveryAction (now part of the Bonterra family) is genuinely one of the most powerful CRM and fundraising platforms built specifically for nonprofits. It does a lot. It can track donors, manage email campaigns, process online gifts, handle advocacy actions, run peer-to-peer fundraising, and produce reporting that your board *might* actually appreciate. For organizations that are doing all of those things at scale, it can be a game-changer.

But here’s the thing nobody tells you before you sign the contract: it is a lot.

And no I’m not just talking about the dollar amount.

The learning curve is steep. The implementation takes longer than you think. And if you don’t have someone on staff (or a consultant you trust) who can manage the system with some real fluency, you’re going to end up with a very expensive tool you’re only using 20% of. I’ve seen it happen. I’ve actually lived it.

What EveryAction does well

The email tools are strong. The online donation forms are customizable in ways that most platforms don’t allow. The advocacy and action alert features are genuinely best-in-class if you’re a policy or organizing shop. And the data infrastructure, when properly maintained, gives you a unified view of your donor relationships that’s hard to replicate elsewhere.

Here are some of my favorite features:

  • Source Codes
  • Automated Workflows
  • Donor Self-Service Portal
  • Native Organizing Features
  • Native Email & Form Customization

Where it gets complicated

First, the pricing. EveryAction is not cheap, and depending on how your contract is structured, costs can scale quickly as your database grows. Make sure you understand what you’re paying for before you sign. Also, their contract terms can be tricky. During both of my contracts with the platform, multi-year options were the only pathways offered and renewals were confusing.

Second, the implementation. Moving your data into a new CRM is never painless, but EveryAction’s data model has enough nuance that a sloppy migration can leave you with records that are messy for years. Invest in proper onboarding. It’s worth it.

Third — and this is the one I see trip people up the most — EveryAction requires ongoing stewardship. It’s not a set-it-and-forget-it tool. Someone on your team needs to own it. Not just “use it,” but own it. Know how the fields map together, understand the reporting logic, and care enough to keep the data clean.

Fourth, and most important in my opinion, you DO NOT need to use all of the features right away. Actually I would professionally recommend that you scale your organization’s use in order to ease yourself into the system. If you are trying to fill fields without realizing how it corresponds to the broader picture of your data, you will most definitely be left with regret months down the line.

So should your organization use it?

If you’re running a development operation with multiple revenue streams, a list of thousands of donors, and any kind of advocacy or organizing component — yes, EveryAction should absolutely be on your radar. It MAY have been built for organizations just like you.

If you’re a small shop with a tight budget and a donor database that fits in a spreadsheet, it might be more tool than you need right now. There are lighter-weight options worth exploring first (and we’ll talk about some of them elsewhere on this blog). Here’s a caveat with the “small shop” reference, if your growth is fervent and you project managing tens of thousands of constituent profiles in the near future then switching early might be less of a headache. However, you must be able to project what that data and flow level looks like in 3-5 years as well.

The real mistake would be adopting EveryAction — or any CRM — without having a clear plan for how you’re going to use it, who’s going to manage it, and how you’re going to keep it clean. The platform isn’t the strategy. It’s the infrastructure that supports your strategy. Get the strategy right first.

Subscribe to The Troop

Enter your email to receive alerts when new articles and issues are published.

Table of Contents

Related Articles